While going through the valley I realized why thy would have traveled that way. First of all there is a small river there and when we are zipping along I-15 you do not see very much water, it seems like the saints would have wandered back and forth to find water. Also this is one of the locations of the old Spanish trail, so it would have been an established road to take.
Heading south down the road to Parowan
Looking southeast
According to some papers that were in the possession of my Great Grandmother, Sarah died in this valley on the way back to Salt Lake. The muddy mission in Nevada was closed when the saints, found out they were in Nevada instead of Arizona and the Nevada government demanded back taxes to be paid in gold. William Dummer's father Charles had already died in St. Thomas Nevada, and William with his family, mother and brothers and sisters and other saints went back to Salt Lake City.